Constructive Ideas on Evacuations
R. Alex Whitlock
In the forum over at blogHOUSTON, Shreela puts up the kinds of ideas I like to see. Specific ways to improve things that take into account possible snags along the way:
1. Contraflow would have bottle-necked once we got out of Houston/Harris Co if things hadn't been coordinated with the government ahead of time, so what good would it have done without the towns-in-the-evac-route's cooperation. Perhaps if Govenor Perry would have mandated certain routes to be contraflowed until point x, including all small cities along the way, it won't be so difficult next time. One of our neighbors told us that once I-10 had finally been contraflowed, other than getting traffic to the other side, everything went really smooth.

2. 18 wheelers! Everyone I've talked to from my neighborhood commented on the vast amounts of 18 wheelers on the road, some of which broke down or ran out of gas.

Maybe they could come up with some type of formula that "all 18-wheelers not involved with emergency supplies will not be allowed to enter a medium or larger city if they're in a strike zone of a cat3+ hurricane within x number of days (or hours), until a time when the hurricane has shifted to x number of miles of striking that particular city".

3. Country roads with wide shoulders. Many of the routes outside of Houston were two-way roads, but had a shoulder that was as wide as the main lane. We saw quite a few people trying to turn the shoulders into a second lane, but there were line-riders (J. B. Hunt 18 wheeler on 1960 eastbound was the worst I saw) blocking people from trying to use the shoulder as a second lane.

I'm fully aware that bottle-necking would occur at intersections that didn't include the shoulders, but we did see some intersections that DID include the shoulder. So, for the wide-shoulder routes that could be converted to two lanes, the line-riders just slowed things down for everyone (with a few exceptions, most of the wide shoulder routes had fairly level grass easements for the people needing to pull over for whatever reasons).

If these types of routes had been predesignated to be turned into two lanes during emergency evacuations, the press could have informed us which roads were considered two lane routes, and the line-riders might have stopped preventing the flow.

Posted to H Town
 
buy cheap softwarecheap softwareoem softwarecheap adobe acrobat  

Observations

 
Kavey wrote:
I like the email my Mother sent me on Houston Evacuation...
City officials just announced a revised Houston 2005 Hurricane Evacuation Plan

Hispanics: Use I-10 West to San Antonio.
Cajuns: Use I-10 East to Lafayette.
Rednecks: Use 59 North to east Texas.
Republicans: Fly Continental to Washington D. C.
Longhorns: Use 290 West to Austin.
Democrats: Use 45 South to Galveston.
AGGIES: USE 610 LOOP!!

YOUR COOPERATION IN THIS MATTER IS GREATLY APPRECIATED!
9/30/2005
 
Kavey wrote:
BTW, not many people are aware of this, but in Texas, a paved shoulder IS a legal lane. Most people aren't crazy enough to drive on the shoulder due to broken down cars, end of shoulder suddenly, etc., but it's something you can already do.

The shoulder idea isn't exactly the greatest. Texans don't know how to properly merge. So if you split the lane out in the country shoulders, and the shoulder ends, it will cause a worse jam as they try and figure out how to merge back together. Really sucks with groups of people who want to stick together and cut in, and let 5 cars in front of them.
9/30/2005
 
ATruett wrote:
That was the problem in some parts of 290. People ride on the shoulder, then realize they're at an overpass with no shoulder or behind a stalled car, and then end up squeezed up nose against the guardrail or the bumper of the stalled car, unable to move forward and blocking not only the off-roaders but also those in the rightmost regular lane.

Of course, those shoulder-riders also contributed to many of the medical problems, by making it impossible for ambulances to pass.
9/30/2005
 
ADAM wrote:
We had police cars on I-45 north of the Woodlands riding the shoulders telling everyone else that was riding the shoulders that unless it was an emergency, you couldn't ride the shoulder.
9/30/2005
 
ATruett wrote:
Additional thought I somehow managed not to think of (even though they pointed it out on TV at the time): riding on the shoulder ain't gonna get anyone (except those who swerve by on the shoulder and then cut in 18 cars up) there any faster, since they still have to go through the narrow spots 2 cars at a time. It just encourages bottlenecks. Of course, if your goal isn't so much to get people to their destination as to get them out of the area, even if they'll be sitting in a bottleneck, that's fine.
9/30/2005

Add an Observation

Comment spam is an ongoing problems that we're trying to address. Previously we required people to create accounts and log in. I am thankful to say that is no longer the case. We're giving Captcha another try and are playing around with a text-based Q&A variant of Captcha. So bear with us as we try to figure out how to best get a handle ont he problem. Please note that any comment on a post more than 30 days old will go into the moderation queue, where I will get to it when I can which could be once a week.

:

:
:



 

 

Home || RSS || Archives || Ten Second News || FURL || Blogrolodexical (Full)