The Dixie Chicks have announced that
country musicians are meanie-poos and they're going to find some new friends they are
leaving country music behind and are going to pursue a rock & roll sound.
Makes sense, after all, nothing screams "rock and roll band" like the name Dixie Chicks.
But I digress. I can't say that this surprises me all that much except in timing. I've always felt that one way or another, Natalie Maines was going to go pop. Despite the upbringing of her Texas county music legend father Lloyd Maines, country music has never been her thing.
I also figured that the band itself would start moving to a more money-making less genred sound, but I figured they'd do it in the vein of Shania Twain of Faith Hill, who've both managed to become pop successes while maintaining the loyalty of most country music fans. They've done so largely by a tactic of deny, deny, deny, accept, then explain that good music comes in all shapes and sizes.
So on one hand, kudos to the Chicks for being honest about their intentions. It's also a bit gutsy when you consider that a banjo and fiddle are not typical in rock (Blue October notwithstanding).
Of course, their rationale is about as lamebrained as their sense of appropriateness:
Violinist Martie Maguire told Spiegel magazine: "We don't feel part of the country scene any longer, it can't be our home any more."
She said she was disappointed other country singers didn't back up the Dixie Chicks in their criticism of George W Bush's politics on Iraq.
"A few weeks ago, Merle Haggard said a couple of nice words about us, but that was it," Maguire complained.
"The support we got came from others, like Bruce Springsteen."
Going home empty-handed from the Country Awards ceremony also made them decide to break with the scene, Maguire said.
"Instead, we won three Grammys against much stronger competition.
"So we now consider ourselves part of the big Rock 'n' Roll family."
That's the equivalent of saying "Y'all [sorry, 'you all' in non-country speak] are mean! We're gonna go find new friends!"
On the other hand, they really were dragged through the mud by other country singers and the complaint could be considered valid to some degree. Toby Keith has had an ongoing "feud" with them predating the remarks, Mark Chestnutt and Brooks and Dunn both made disparaging remarks at the Houston Rodeo.
That said, they were not exactly supportive of Toby Keith's own political statement ("It's ignorant, and it makes country music sound ignorant. It targets an entire culture - and not just the bad people who did bad things.
You've got to have some tact." she said weeks before she said she was ashamed of the President on foreign soil) and it's a bit unrealist to expect fellow musicians to take a bullet flung by their common fan base. If you're gonna dish it out, you gotta be able to take it.
Or you can do as they are and take your ball and go home.
The unfortunate thing is that unlike Kevin and Scott, I
do like the Dixie Chicks music. They are (were) one of my more favored Nashville acts. Natalie's got a great singing voice and while they're song-leaches (ie don't write their own material), they tend to have pretty good taste in songs. They also bought a more unique sound to a bland town that very much needed it.
But they seem to have an air of superiority that doesn't fly in country music (unless you have Shania Twain's figure) and a sense of cultural elitism aimed at the very fans that propelled them to stardom. Tragic, but inevitable.
Aww, come on, Alex... where's one of your patented Shania Twain graphics for Natalie Moo now?
I mean, seriously. She can be miffed that people got mad at her all she wants -- just shows how left-leaning, and stuck up, she is.
Then again I don't really like their music to start with.
The only problem I had with their political ejaculation was that they decided to do it outside the country *first* which lands them in the "Jane Fonda Memorial Prisoner of War Camp" for me.
In general, I couldn't care less about a celebrity's politics any more than I care about their sexual orientation. Being in a movie or having a CD doesn't magically bequeath political enlightenment and I'm consistently amazed that anyone thinks it does.
Natalie did, however, show that she ain't the smartest business cookies in the jar. Only an idiot or an arrogant ass goes out of their way to offend their primary customer. The subsequent half-assed attempts at explanation or apology accomplished neither and everyone knew it.
Oh, yeah, you can also be a huge industry association, too... that also gives you license to slam (and sue) your customers.
The Dixie Chicks had a watered-down, formulaic country sound and I think they'll probably have a watered-down, formulaic rock sound.
Which makes them absolutely perfect for pop music and as soon as they drop "Dixie" (what self-respecting left-winger could possibly associate themselves with THAT?) to become "The Chicks" (or possibly just "Chix") I fully expect them to have 2005's biggest selling album.
Comment spam is an ongoing problems that we're trying to address. Previously we required people to create accounts and log in. I am thankful to say that is no longer the case. We're giving Captcha another try and are playing around with a text-based Q&A variant of Captcha. So bear with us as we try to figure out how to best get a handle ont he problem. Please note that any comment on a post more than 30 days old will go into the moderation queue, where I will get to it when I can which could be once a week.